Revisiting of Environmental variables precendence (#15396)

* Rewriting based on knowledge transfer
* Fix and minor edits
This commit is contained in:
Dockertopia 2022-08-16 16:48:45 +01:00 committed by GitHub
parent 0f78616c7a
commit fa2fd4f915
No known key found for this signature in database
GPG Key ID: 4AEE18F83AFDEB23
1 changed files with 34 additions and 32 deletions

View File

@ -1,40 +1,42 @@
---
title: Environment variables precedence
description: TODO
description: Scenario Overview illustrating how environmental variables are resolved in Compose
keywords: compose, environment, env file
---
<style>
div {
color: RoyalBlue;
}
table {
font-family: monospace;
}
</style>
## Order of precedence
1. Passed from the command-line [`docker compose run --env <KEY[=VAL]>`](../../engine/reference/commandline/compose_run/#options).
2. Passed from/set in `compose.yaml` service's configuration, [from the environment key](../../compose/compose-file/#environment).
3. Passed from/set in `compose.yaml` service's configuration, [from the env_file key](../../compose/compose-file/#env_file).
4. Passed from/set in Container Image [in ENV directive](../../engine/reference/builder/#env).
- Command Line (docker compose run --env <KEY[=VAL]> https://docs.docker.com/engine/reference/commandline/compose_run/#options)
- Compose File (service::environment section: https://docs.docker.com/compose/compose-file/#environment)
- Compose File (service::env_file section file: https://docs.docker.com/compose/compose-file/#env_file)
- Container Image ENV directive (https://docs.docker.com/engine/reference/builder/#env)
### Precedence quick overview table
The table below provides a quick overview of how interpolation works when using all environment variables on Compose, using `TAG`, an environmental variable defining the version for an image, as an example.
When `WHEREAMI` is the variable in case:
Each row represents a scenario and each columns represents a context where you can be setting or passing an environment variable.
| Image (`ENV` directive in Dockerfile) | OS Environment | `.env` file on the project root (or overwrite through `docker compose -env-file <FILE>`) | Compose file (`service::env_file`) | Compose file (`service::environment`) | Command line (docker compose run -e <KEY[=VAL]>) | RESULT |
|:-------------------------------------:|:-----------------:|:-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------:|:----------------------------------:|:-----------------------------------------:|:------------------------------------------------:|:------------------------:|
| <div>Dockerfile</div> | OS_Env | WHEREAMI=DotEnv_File | | | | Dockerfile |
| Dockerfile | OS_Env | WHEREAMI=<div>DotEnv_File</div> | | | WHEREAMI | DotEnv_File |
| Dockerfile | <div>OS_Env</div> | WHEREAMI=${WHEREAMI:-DotEnv_File_DefaultValue} | | | WHEREAMI | OS_Env |
| <div>Dockerfile</div> | OS_Env | WHEREAMI=${WHEREAMI:-DotEnv_File_DefaultValue} | | | | Dockerfile |
| Dockerfile | | WHEREAMI=${WHEREAMI:-<div>DotEnv_File_DefaultValue</div>} | | | WHEREAMI | DotEnv_File_DefaultValue |
| Dockerfile | OS_Env | WHEREAMI=${WHEREAMI:-DotEnv_File_DefaultValue} | | | WHEREAMI=<div>Command_Line</div> | Command_Line |
| Dockerfile | <div>OS_Env</div> | WHEREAMI=${WHEREAMI:-DotEnv_File_DefaultValue} | | WHEREAMI | | OS_Env |
| Dockerfile | OS_Env | WHEREAMI=${WHEREAMI:-DotEnv_File_DefaultValue} | | WHEREAMI=<div>Environment_Section</div> | | Environment_Section |
| Dockerfile | OS_Env | WHEREAMI=${WHEREAMI:-DotEnv_File_DefaultValue} | | WHEREAMI=Environment_Section | WHEREAMI=<div>Command_Line</div> | Command_Line |
| Dockerfile | <div>OS_Env</div> | WHEREAMI=${WHEREAMI:-DotEnv_File_DefaultValue} | | WHEREAMI=Environment_Section | WHEREAMI | OS_Env |
| Dockerfile | OS_Env | WHEREAMI=${WHEREAMI:-DotEnv_File_DefaultValue} | | WHEREAMI | WHEREAMI=<div>Command_Line</div> | Command_Line |
| Dockerfile | OS_Env | | WHEREAMI=Env_File | | WHEREAMI=<div>Command_Line</div> | Command_Line |
| Dockerfile | OS_Env | | WHEREAMI=Env_File | WHEREAMI=<div>Environment_Section</div> | | Environment_Section |
| Dockerfile | OS_Env | | WHEREAMI=<div>Env_File</div> | | | Env_File |
| Dockerfile | <div>OS_Env</div> | | | WHEREAMI=${WHEREAMI:-Environment_Section} | | OS_Env |
| Dockerfile | <div>OS_Env</div> | WHEREAMI=${WHEREAMI:-DotEnv_File_DefaultValue} | | WHEREAMI=${WHEREAMI:-Environment_Section} | | OS_Env |
| # | `.env` file | `compose.yaml`:`env_file` key | `compose.yaml`:`environment` key | CMD | Image | OS | Resolved as |
|:-:|:--------------------------:|:-----------------------------:|:---------------------------------:|:------------:|:-------------:|:------------:|:-----------------:|
| 1 | `TAG=1.3` | Unset | Unset | - | `TAG=1.6` | `TAG=1.4` | `TAG=1.6` |
| 2 | `TAG=1.3` | Unset | Unset | `TAG` | `TAG=1.6` | `TAG=1.4` | `TAG=1.3` |
| 3 | `TAG=$TAG:-1.2` | Unset | Unset | `TAG` | `TAG=1.6` | `TAG=1.4` | `TAG=1.4` |
| 4 | `TAG=$TAG:-1.2` | Unset | Unset | - | `TAG=1.6` | `TAG=1.4` | `TAG=1.6` |
| 5 | `TAG=$TAG:-1.2` | Unset | Unset | `TAG` | `TAG=1.6` | - | `TAG=1.6` |
| 6 | `TAG=$TAG:-1.2` | Unset | Unset | `TAG=1.5` | `TAG=1.6` | `TAG=1.4` | `TAG=1.5` |
| 7 | `TAG=$TAG:-1.2` | Unset | `TAG` | - | `TAG=1.6` | `TAG=1.4` | `TAG=1.4` |
| 8 | `TAG=$TAG:-1.2` | Unset | `TAG=1.7` | `TAG` | `TAG=1.6` | `TAG=1.4` | `TAG=1.7` |
| 9 | `TAG=$TAG:-1.2` | Unset | `TAG=1.7` | `TAG=1.5` | `TAG=1.6` | `TAG=1.4` | `TAG=1.5` |
| 10| `TAG=$TAG:-1.2` | Unset | `TAG` | `TAG` | `TAG=1.6` | `TAG=1.4` | `TAG=1.4` |
| 11| `TAG=$TAG:-1.2` | Unset | `TAG` | `TAG` | `TAG=1.6` | `TAG=1.4` | `TAG=1.4` |
| 12| `TAG=$TAG:-1.2` | `TAG=1.8` | - | **`TAG=1.5`** | `TAG=1.6` | `TAG=1.4` | `TAG=1.5` |
| 13| `TAG=$TAG:-1.2` | `TAG=1.8` | **`TAG=1.7`** | `TAG=1.5` | `TAG=1.6` | `TAG=1.4` | `TAG=1.7` |
| 14| - |**`TAG=1.8`** | - | - | `TAG=1.6` | `TAG=1.4` | `TAG=1.8` |
| 15| - | - | `TAG=1.7` | - | `TAG=1.6` | `TAG=1.4` | `TAG=1.4` |
| 16| - | - | `TAG=1.7` | - | `TAG=1.6` | `TAG=1.4` | `TAG=1.4` |
Description for each column:
* Image - `ENV` directive in the Dockerfile
* .env file - `.env` file on the project root (or, with higher precedence, the file passed via `docker compose -env-file <FILE>`).
* Command line - environmental variable passed via `docker compose run -e <KEY[=VAL]>`.
* Compose file - in `environment` key from the service section in the `compose.yaml`.
* Compose file - in `env_file key` from the service section in the `compose.yaml`.