Always start from the first address after a successful connection.

core/src/main/java/io/grpc/internal/TransportSet.java

@@ -77,12 +77,11 @@ final class TransportSet {
   @GuardedBy("lock")
   private BackoffPolicy reconnectPolicy;
 
-  // The address index from which the current series of consecutive failing connection attempts
+  // True if the next connect attempt is the first attempt ever, or the one right after a successful
-  // started. -1 means the current series have not started.
+  // connection (i.e., transportReady() was called).  If true, the next connect attempt will start
-  // In the case of consecutive failures, the time between two attempts for this address is
+  // from the first address and will reset back-off.
-  // controlled by connectPolicy.
   @GuardedBy("lock")
-  private int headIndex = -1;
+  private boolean firstAttempt = true;
 
   @GuardedBy("lock")
   private final Stopwatch backoffWatch;
@@ -176,6 +175,9 @@ final class TransportSet {
     Preconditions.checkState(reconnectTask == null || reconnectTask.isDone(),
         "previous reconnectTask is not done");
 
+    if (firstAttempt) {
+      nextAddressIndex = 0;
+    }
     final int currentAddressIndex = nextAddressIndex;
     List<SocketAddress> addrs = addressGroup.getAddresses();
     final SocketAddress address = addrs.get(currentAddressIndex);
@@ -192,7 +194,7 @@ final class TransportSet {
         boolean savedShutdown;
         synchronized (lock) {
           savedShutdown = shutdown;
-          if (currentAddressIndex == headIndex) {
+          if (currentAddressIndex == 0) {
             backoffWatch.reset().start();
           }
           newActiveTransport = transportFactory.newClientTransport(address, authority);
@@ -224,19 +226,18 @@ final class TransportSet {
       }
     };
 
-    long delayMillis;
+    long delayMillis = 0;
-    if (currentAddressIndex == headIndex) {
+    if (currentAddressIndex == 0) {
-      // Back to the first attempted address. Calculate back-off delay.
+      if (firstAttempt) {
+        // First connect attempt, or the first attempt since last successful connection.
+        reconnectPolicy = backoffPolicyProvider.get();
+      } else {
+        // Back to the first address. Calculate back-off delay.
         delayMillis =
             reconnectPolicy.nextBackoffMillis() - backoffWatch.elapsed(TimeUnit.MILLISECONDS);
-    } else {
-      delayMillis = 0;
-      if (headIndex == -1) {
-        // First connect attempt, or the first attempt since last successful connection.
-        headIndex = currentAddressIndex;
-        reconnectPolicy = backoffPolicyProvider.get();
       }
     }
+    firstAttempt = false;
     if (delayMillis <= 0) {
       reconnectTask = null;
       // No back-off this time.
@@ -333,7 +334,7 @@ final class TransportSet {
       super.transportReady();
       synchronized (lock) {
         if (isAttachedToActiveTransport()) {
-          headIndex = -1;
+          firstAttempt = true;
         }
       }
       loadBalancer.handleTransportReady(addressGroup);

core/src/test/java/io/grpc/internal/ManagedChannelImplTransportManagerTest.java

@@ -248,7 +248,7 @@ public class ManagedChannelImplTransportManagerTest {
     // Second pick fails. This is the beginning of a series of failures.
     ClientTransport t2 = tm.getTransport(addressGroup);
     assertNotNull(t2);
-    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr2)).newClientTransport(addr2, authority);
+    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr1)).newClientTransport(addr1, authority);
     // Back-off policy was reset.
     verify(mockBackoffPolicyProvider, times(++backoffReset)).get();
     transports.poll().listener.transportShutdown(Status.UNAVAILABLE);
@@ -256,15 +256,15 @@ public class ManagedChannelImplTransportManagerTest {
     // Third pick fails too
     ClientTransport t3 = tm.getTransport(addressGroup);
     assertNotNull(t3);
-    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr1)).newClientTransport(addr1, authority);
+    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr2)).newClientTransport(addr2, authority);
     // Back-off policy was not reset.
     verify(mockBackoffPolicyProvider, times(backoffReset)).get();
     transports.poll().listener.transportShutdown(Status.UNAVAILABLE);
 
-    // Forth pick is on addr2, back-off policy kicks in.
+    // Forth pick is on the first address, back-off policy kicks in.
     ClientTransport t4 = tm.getTransport(addressGroup);
     assertNotNull(t4);
-    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr2)).newClientTransport(addr2, authority);
+    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr1)).newClientTransport(addr1, authority);
     // Back-off policy was not reset, but was consulted.
     verify(mockBackoffPolicyProvider, times(backoffReset)).get();
     verify(mockBackoffPolicy, times(++backoffConsulted)).nextBackoffMillis();

core/src/test/java/io/grpc/internal/TransportSetTest.java

@@ -176,82 +176,52 @@ public class TransportSetTest {
     transportSet.obtainActiveTransport();
     verify(mockBackoffPolicyProvider, times(++backoffReset)).get();
     verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr1)).newClientTransport(addr1, authority);
-    // Let this one through
+    // Let this one fail without success
-    transports.peek().listener.transportReady();
-    // Then shut it down
-    transports.poll().listener.transportShutdown(Status.UNAVAILABLE);
-
-
-    ////// Now start a series of failing attempts, where addr2 is the head.
-    // First attempt after a connection closed. Reset back-off policy.
-    transportSet.obtainActiveTransport();
-    verify(mockBackoffPolicyProvider, times(++backoffReset)).get();
-    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr2)).newClientTransport(addr2, authority);
-    // Fail this one
     transports.poll().listener.transportShutdown(Status.UNAVAILABLE);
 
     // Second attempt will start immediately. Keep back-off policy.
     transportSet.obtainActiveTransport();
     verify(mockBackoffPolicyProvider, times(backoffReset)).get();
-    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr1)).newClientTransport(addr1, authority);
+    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr2)).newClientTransport(addr2, authority);
     // Fail this one too
     transports.poll().listener.transportShutdown(Status.UNAVAILABLE);
 
-    // Third attempt is on head, thus controlled by the first back-off interval.
+    // Third attempt is the first address, thus controlled by the first back-off interval.
     transportSet.obtainActiveTransport();
-    verify(mockBackoffPolicy2, times(++backoff2Consulted)).nextBackoffMillis();
+    verify(mockBackoffPolicy1, times(++backoff1Consulted)).nextBackoffMillis();
     verify(mockBackoffPolicyProvider, times(backoffReset)).get();
     fakeClock.forwardMillis(9);
-    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(transportsAddr2)).newClientTransport(addr2, authority);
+    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(transportsAddr1)).newClientTransport(addr1, authority);
     fakeClock.forwardMillis(1);
-    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr2)).newClientTransport(addr2, authority);
+    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr1)).newClientTransport(addr1, authority);
     // Fail this one too
     transports.poll().listener.transportShutdown(Status.UNAVAILABLE);
 
     // Forth attempt will start immediately. Keep back-off policy.
     transportSet.obtainActiveTransport();
     verify(mockBackoffPolicyProvider, times(backoffReset)).get();
-    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr1)).newClientTransport(addr1, authority);
+    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr2)).newClientTransport(addr2, authority);
     // Fail this one too
     transports.poll().listener.transportShutdown(Status.UNAVAILABLE);
 
-    // Fifth attempt is on head, thus controlled by the second back-off interval.
+    // Fifth attempt for the first address, thus controlled by the second back-off interval.
     transportSet.obtainActiveTransport();
-    verify(mockBackoffPolicy2, times(++backoff2Consulted)).nextBackoffMillis();
+    verify(mockBackoffPolicy1, times(++backoff1Consulted)).nextBackoffMillis();
     verify(mockBackoffPolicyProvider, times(backoffReset)).get();
     fakeClock.forwardMillis(99);
-    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(transportsAddr2)).newClientTransport(addr2, authority);
+    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(transportsAddr1)).newClientTransport(addr1, authority);
     fakeClock.forwardMillis(1);
-    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr2)).newClientTransport(addr2, authority);
+    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr1)).newClientTransport(addr1, authority);
     // Let it through
     transports.peek().listener.transportReady();
     // Then close it.
     transports.poll().listener.transportShutdown(Status.UNAVAILABLE);
 
-
+    // First attempt after a successful connection. Reset back-off policy, and start from the first
-    ////// Now start a series of failing attempts, where addr1 is the head.
+    // address.
-    // First attempt after a connection closed. Reset back-off policy.
     transportSet.obtainActiveTransport();
     verify(mockBackoffPolicyProvider, times(++backoffReset)).get();
     verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr1)).newClientTransport(addr1, authority);
-    // Fail this one
-    transports.poll().listener.transportShutdown(Status.UNAVAILABLE);
-
-    // Second attempt will start immediately. Keep back-off policy.
-    transportSet.obtainActiveTransport();
-    verify(mockBackoffPolicyProvider, times(backoffReset)).get();
-    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr2)).newClientTransport(addr2, authority);
-    // Fail this one too
-    transports.poll().listener.transportShutdown(Status.UNAVAILABLE);
-
-    // Third attempt is on head, thus controlled by the first back-off interval.
-    transportSet.obtainActiveTransport();
-    verify(mockBackoffPolicy3, times(++backoff3Consulted)).nextBackoffMillis();
-    verify(mockBackoffPolicyProvider, times(backoffReset)).get();
-    fakeClock.forwardMillis(9);
-    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(transportsAddr1)).newClientTransport(addr1, authority);
-    fakeClock.forwardMillis(1);
-    verify(mockTransportFactory, times(++transportsAddr1)).newClientTransport(addr1, authority);
 
     // Final checks on invocations on back-off policies
     verify(mockBackoffPolicy1, times(backoff1Consulted)).nextBackoffMillis();