- Log counts of Authzs where CAA was rechecked/reused.
- Move the CAA recheck duration to a single variable in the RA.
- Add new method `InfoObject` to our logger.
Fixes#6560
Part of #6623
`ReuseValidAuthz` was introduced
here [1] and enabled in staging and production configs on 2016-07-13.
There was a brief stint during the TLS-SNI-01 challenge type removal where
SRE disabled it. However, time has finally come to remove this configuration
option. Issue #6623 will determine the feasibility of shorter authz
lifetimes and potentially the removal of authz reuse.
This change is broken up into two parts to allow SRE to safely remove
the flag from staging and production configs. We'll merge this PR, SRE
will deploy boulder and the config change, then we'll finish removing
`ReuseValidAuthz` configuration from the codebase.
[1] boulder commit 9abc212448
Part 1 of 2 for fixing #2734.
For consistency, put the error field at the end of unstructured log
lines to make them more ... structured.
Adds the `issuerID` field to "orphaning certificate" log line in the CA
to match the "orphaning precertificate" log line.
Fixes broken tests as a result of the CA and bdns log line change.
Fixes#5457
Simplify the control flow of the FinalizeOrder handler to make it easier
to read and reason about:
- Move all validation to before we set the order to Processing, and put
it all in a single helper funcion.
- Move almost all logEvent/trace handling directly into FinalizeOrder so
it cannot be missed.
- Flatten issueCertificate and issueCertificateInner into a single
helper function, now that they're no longer being called from both
ACMEv1 and v2 entry points.
- Other minor cleanups, such as making SolvedBy not return a pointer and
making matchesCSR private.
This paves the way for making both issueCertificateInner and failOrder
asynchronous, which we plan to do in the near future.
Part of #6575
The core.CertificateRequest wrapper type only had two fields: an
x509.CertificateRequest, and a slice of bytes representing the unparsed
version of the same request. However, x509.CertificateRequest carries
around its own field .Raw, which serves the same purpose. Also, we
weren't even referencing the .Bytes field anyway. Therefore, get rid of
this redundant wrapper type.
This also makes it clearer just how far the original CSR makes it
through our system. I'd like a future change to remove the CSR from the
request to the CA service, replacing it with a structured object that
only exposes exactly the fields of the CSR we care about, such as names,
public key, and whether or not the must-staple extension should be set.
Although we have a metric for counting how often we reuse a valid
authorization, no code has been incrementing that metric since 2021.
Re-enable it.
Additionally, that metric doesn't help us know how old authorizations
are when they get reused, which is useful information when deciding
whether or how much to shrink our authorization reuse lifetime. Add a
new histogram metric to track the ages of authorizations when they're
attached to an order.
Deprecate these feature flags, which are consistently set in both prod
and staging and which we do not expect to change the value of ever
again:
- AllowReRevocation
- AllowV1Registration
- CheckFailedAuthorizationsFirst
- FasterNewOrdersRateLimit
- GetAuthzReadOnly
- GetAuthzUseIndex
- MozRevocationReasons
- RejectDuplicateCSRExtensions
- RestrictRSAKeySizes
- SHA1CSRs
Move each feature flag to the "deprecated" section of features.go.
Remove all references to these feature flags from Boulder application
code, and make the code they were guarding the only path. Deduplicate
tests which were testing both the feature-enabled and feature-disabled
code paths. Remove the flags from all config-next JSON configs (but
leave them in config ones until they're fully deleted, not just
deprecated). Finally, replace a few testdata CSRs used in CA tests,
because they had SHA1WithRSAEncryption signatures that are now rejected.
Fixes#5171Fixes#6476
Part of #5997
Have the database query return timestamps for when certificates
were issued for certain names. Use that information to compute
when the next time that name will be eligible for issuance again.
Include that timestamp in the error message and a Retry-After
HTTP header.
Fixes#6465
Rather than simply refusing to write OCSP Response bytes to the
database (which is what ROCSP Stage 6 did), Stage 7 refuses to
even generate those bytes in the first place. We obviously can't
disable OCSP Response generation in the CA, since it still needs to
be usable by the ocsp-responder's live-signing path, so instead we
disable it in all of the non-live-signing codepaths (orphan finder,
issue precertificate, revoke certificate, and re-revoke certificate)
which have previously called GenerateOCSP.
Part of #6285
When the RA is generating OCSP (as part of new issuance, revocation,
or when its own GenerateOCSP method is called by the ocsp-responder)
have it use the CA's dedicated OCSPGenerator service, rather than
calling the method exposed by the CA's catch-all CertificateAuthority
service. To facilitate this, add a new GRPCClientConfig stanza to the
RA.
This change will allow us to remove the GenerateOCSP and GenerateCRL
methods from the catch-all CertificateAuthority service, allowing us to
independently control which kinds of objects the CA is willing to sign
by turning off individual service interfaces. The RA's new config stanza
will need to be populated in prod before further changes are possible.
Fixes#6451
- Add a new field, `RetryAfter` to `BoulderError`s
- Add logic to wrap/unwrap the value of the `RetryAfter` field to our gRPC error
interceptor
- Plumb `RetryAfter` for `DuplicateCertificateError` emitted by RA to the WFE
client response header
Part of #6256
Previously, the reloader relied on user code to log errors and changes.
But this led to gaps (for instance the RA not logging reloads of the rate
limit file). Instead, make the reloader responsible for this.
This allowed removing the error callback, at the minor cost of removing
the status gauge for the ECDSA allowlist.
According to the documentation for certificateRequestEvent:
// CommonName is the subject common name from the issued cert
CommonName string `json:",omitempty"`
// Names are the DNS SAN entries from the issued cert
Names []string `json:",omitempty"`
We were erroneously setting these based on the CSR, not the issued
certificate.
Enable the "unparam" linter, which checks for unused function
parameters, unused function return values, and parameters and
return values that always have the same value every time they
are used.
In addition, fix many instances where the unparam linter complains
about our existing codebase. Remove error return values from a
number of functions that never return an error, remove or use
context and test parameters that were previously unused, and
simplify a number of (mostly test-only) functions that always take the
same value for their parameter. Most notably, remove the ability to
customize the RSA Public Exponent from the ceremony tooling,
since it should always be 65537 anyway.
Fixes#6104
Run the Boulder unit and integration tests with go1.19.
In addition, make a few small changes to allow both sets of
tests to run side-by-side. Mark a few tests, including our lints
and generate checks, as go1.18-only. Reformat a few doc
comments, particularly lists, to abide by go1.19's stricter gofmt.
Causes #6275
The Fragment field of a parsed URL is only non-empty if there is
text following the octothorpe character. Check for the case that
the mailto: address ends in an octothorpe with no trailing value.
Fixes#6231
- Modify `ra.checkCertificatesPerFQDNSetLimit()` to use a leaky bucket algorithm
- Return issuance timestamps from `sa.FQDNSetTimestampsForWindow()` in descending order
Resolves#6154
Add a new filter to mail-test-srv, allowing test processes to query
for messages sent from a specific address, not just ones sent to
a specific address. This fixes a race condition in the revocation
integration tests where the number of messages sent to a cert's
contact address would be higher than expected because expiration
mailer sent a message while the test was running. Also reduce
bad-key-revoker's maximum backoff to 2 seconds to ensure that
it continues to run frequently during the integration tests, despite
usually not having any work to do.
While we're here, also improve the comments on various revocation
integration tests, remove some unnecessary cruft, and split the tests
out to explicitly test functionality with the MozRevocationReasons
flag both enabled and disabled. Also, change ocsp_helper's default
output from os.Stdout to ioutil.Discard to prevent hundreds of lines
of log spam when the integration tests fail during a test that uses
that library.
Fixes#6248
Add a new `GenerateOCSP` gRPC method to the RA, which
passes the request through to the CA and returns the resulting
OCSP response bytes. This method does not store the new
response anywhere, it is up to the client (in this case intended to
be the new ocsp-responder's live-signing code path) to store it
in any/all appropriate locations.
Fixes#6189
These new linters are almost all part of golangci-lint's collection
of default linters, that would all be running if we weren't setting
`disable-all: true`. By adding them, we now have parity with the
default configuration, as well as the additional linters we like.
Adds the following linters:
* unconvert
* deadcode
* structcheck
* typecheck
* varcheck
* wastedassign
If a Redis client is configured for the SA service, OCSP responses created
during a revocation event will be written to Redis on a best effort basis.
Use the OCSP response NextUpdate time as the expiration time for the
redis entry. Change the new issuance OCSP storage to do the same.
Fixes#5888
Simplify the WFE `RevokeCertificate` API method in three ways:
- Remove most of the logic checking if the requester is authorized to
revoke the certificate in question (based on who is making the
request, what authorizations they have, and what reason they're
requesting). That checking is now done by the RA. Instead, simply
verify that the JWS is authenticated.
- Remove the hard-to-read `authorizedToRevoke` callbacks, and make the
`revokeCertBySubscriberKey` (nee `revokeCertByKeyID`) and
`revokeCertByCertKey` (nee `revokeCertByJWK`) helpers much more
straight-line in their execution logic.
- Call the RA's new `RevokeCertByApplicant` and `RevokeCertByKey` gRPC
methods, rather than the deprecated `RevokeCertificateWithReg`.
This change, without any flag flips, should be invisible to the
end-user. It will slightly change some of our log message formats.
However, by now relying on the new RA gRPC revocation methods, this
change allows us to change our revocation policies by enabling the
`AllowDoubleRevocation` and `MozRevocationReasons` feature flags, which
affect the behavior of those new helpers.
Fixes#5936
Add two new gRPC methods to the SA:
- `RevokeCertByKey` will be used when the API request was signed by the
certificate's keypair, rather than a Subscriber keypair. If the
request is for reason `keyCompromise`, it will ensure that the key is
added to the blocked keys table, and will attempt to "re-revoke" a
certificate that was already revoked for some other reason.
- `RevokeCertByApplicant` supports both the path where the original
subscriber or another account which has proven control over all of the
identifier in the certificate requests revocation via the API. It does
not allow the requested reason to be `keyCompromise`, as these
requests do not represent a demonstration of key compromise.
In addition, add a new feature flag `MozRevocationReasons` which
controls the behavior of these new methods. If the flag is not set, they
behave like they have historically (see above). If the flag is set to true,
then the new methods enforce the upcoming Mozilla policies around
revocation reasons, namely:
- Only the original Subscriber can choose the revocation reason; other
clients will get a set reason code based on the method of requesting
revocation. When the original Subscriber requests reason
`keyCompromise`, this request will be honored, but the key will not be
blocked and other certificates with that key will not also be revoked.
- Revocations signed with the certificate key will always get reason
`keyCompromise`, because we do not know who is sending the request and
therefore must assume that the use of the key in this way represents
compromise. Because these requests will always be fore reason
`keyCompromise`, they will always be added to the blocked keys table
and they will always attempt "re-revocation".
- Revocations authorized via control of all names in the cert will
always get reason `cessationOfOperation`, which is to be used when the
original Subscriber does not control all names in the certificate
anymore.
Finally, update the existing `AdministrativelyRevokeCertificate` method
to use the new helper functions shared by the two new methods.
Part of #5936
We have decided that we don't like the if err := call(); err != nil
syntax, because it creates confusing scopes, but we have not cleaned up
all existing instances of that syntax. However, we have now found a
case where that syntax enables a bug: It caused readers to believe that
a later err = call() statement was assigning to an already-declared err
in the local scope, when in fact it was assigning to an
already-declared err in the parent scope of a closure. This caused our
ineffassign and staticcheck linters to be unable to analyze the
lifetime of the err variable, and so they did not complain when we
never checked the actual value of that error.
This change standardizes on the two-line error checking syntax
everywhere, so that we can more easily ensure that our linters are
correctly analyzing all error assignments.
Incidents of key compromise where proof is supplied in the form of a private key
have historically been labor intensive for SRE. This PR seeks to automate the
process of embedded public key validation , query for issuance, revocation, and
blocking by SPKI hash.
For an example of private keys embedding a mismatched public key, see:
https://blog.hboeck.de/archives/888-How-I-tricked-Symantec-with-a-Fake-Private-Key.html.
Adds two new sub-commands (private-key-block and private-key-revoke) and one new
flag (-dry-run) to admin-revoker. Both new sub-commands validate that the
provided private key and provide the operator with an issuance count. Any
blocking and revocation actions are gated by the new '-dry-run' flag, which is
'true' by default.
private-key-block: if -dry-run=false, will immediately block issuance for the
provided key. The operator is informed that bad-key-revoker will eventually
revoke any certificates using the provided key.
private-key-revoke: if -dry-run=false, will revoke all certificates using the
provided key and then blocks future issuance. This avoids a race with the
bad-key-revoker. This command will execute successfully even if issuance for the
provided key is already blocked.
- Add support for blocking issuance by private key to admin-revoker
- Add support for revoking certificates by private key to admin-revoker
- Create new package called 'privatekey'
- Move private key loading logic from 'issuance' to 'privatekey'
- Add embedded public key verification to 'privatekey'
- Add new field `skipBlockKey` to `AdministrativelyRevokeCertificate` protobuf
- Add check in RA to ensure that only KeyCompromise revocations use
`skipBlockKey`
Fixes#5785
These gRPC methods were only used by the ACMEv1 code paths.
Now that boulder-wfe has been fully removed, we can be confident
that no clients ever call these methods, and can remove them from
the gRPC service interface.
Part of #5816
Empty the bodies of the WFE's and RA's `NewAuthorization` methods. These
were used exclusively by the ACMEv1 flow. Also remove any helper functions
which were used exclusively by this code, and any tests which were testing
exclusively this code and which have equivalent tests for the ACMEv2 flow.
Greatly simply `SA.GetAuthorizations2`, as it no longer has to contend with
there being two different kinds of authorizations in the database. Add a few
TODOs to consider removing a few other SA gRPC methods which no longer
have any callers.
Part of #5681
The NewCertificate codepath was the ACME v1 API's equivalent of
the modern Finalize endpoint. Remove the bodies of the WFE's and
the RA's `NewCertificate` functions. Remove the functions which were
called only from those functions. One of the removed functions is the
old `checkAuthorizations`, so update some tests which were calling
that directly to instead use different entry points.
Part of #5681
These hashes are useful for OCSP computations, as they are the two
values that are used to uniquely identify the issuer of the given cert in
an OCSP request. Here, they are restricted to SHA1 only, as Boulder
only supports SHA1 for OCSP, as per RFC 5019.
In addition, because the `ID`, `NameID`, `NameHash`, and `KeyHash`
are relatively expensive to compute, introduce a new constructor for
`issuance.Certificate` that computes all four values at startup time and
then simply returns the precomputed values when asked.
Today, the revocation codepaths involve parsing the to-be-revoked
certificate multiple times: inside `admin-revoker` itself, inside the
RA's `AdministrativelyRevokeCertificate` method, and again in its helper
`revokeCertificate`. In addition, we use the fact that we have the full
certificate multiple times: to log various attributes of it, to compute
its `IssuerNameID`, and more. All of this will fail if we ever issue a
cert that is malformed to the point that it cannot be parsed.
Add a new argument to the `AdministrativelyRevokeCertificateRequest`
that allows the certificate to be identified by serial only, instead of
by full certificate bytes. Add support for this in the gRPC handler by
using the serial to construct a dummy in-memory Certificate object.
Support this in the `revokeCertificate` codepath by checking to see if
the passed-in cert has any underlying raw DER bytes, and if not,
triggering the new codepath that does everything via the serial.
In order to support this, unfortunately we have to add a second
in-memory map to the RA, so that it can look up issuer certs by either
name ID or old-style ID, as the IDs gleaned from the database (instead
of from the cert itself) may still be old-style. This will be removed
when the old-style Issuer IDs have aged out.
Fixes#5759
When a valid authorization is stored in the database the authorization
column attemptedAt is set based on the challenge `Validated` value. Use
this value in `checkAuthorizationsCAA` to determine if an authorization
is sufficiently stale to need a recheck of the CAA DNS record. Error if the
time is nil. Keeps old codepath for safety check and increments a metric
if the old codepath is used.
Remove the last of the gRPC wrapper files. In order to do so:
- Remove the `core.StorageGetter` interface. Replace it with a new
interface (whose methods include the `...grpc.CallOption` arg)
inside the `sa/proto/` package.
- Remove the `core.StorageAdder` interface. There's no real use-case
for having a write-only interface.
- Remove the `core.StorageAuthority` interface, as it is now redundant
with the autogenerated `sapb.StorageAuthorityClient` interface.
- Replace the `certificateStorage` interface (which appears in two
different places) with a single unified interface also in `sa/proto/`.
- Update all test mocks to include the `_ ...grpc.CallOption` arg in
their method signatures so they match the gRPC client interface.
- Delete many methods from mocks which are no longer necessary (mostly
because they're mocking old authz1 methods that no longer exist).
- Move the two `test/inmem/` wrappers into their own sub-packages to
avoid an import cycle.
- Simplify the `satest` package to satisfy one of its TODOs and to
avoid an import cycle.
- Add many methods to the `test/inmem/sa/` wrapper, to accommodate all
of the methods which are called in unittests.
Fixes#5600
`enforceNameCounts` takes a slice of names as an input and returns a slice
of domain names that are over limit. Return the badNames in the same order
they were input.
Fixes: #5631
Add a new method to the SA's gRPC interface which takes both an Order
and a list of new Authorizations to insert into the database, and adds
both (as well as the various ancillary rows) inside a transaction.
To enable this, add a new abstraction layer inside the `db/` package
that facilitates inserting many rows at once, as we do for the `authz2`,
`orderToAuthz2`, and `requestedNames` tables in this operation.
Finally, add a new codepath to the RA (and a feature flag to control it)
which uses this new SA method instead of separately calling the
`NewAuthorization` method multiple times. Enable this feature flag in
the config-next integration tests.
This should reduce the failure rate of the new-order flow by reducing
the number of database operations by coalescing multiple inserts into a
single multi-row insert. It should also reduce the incidence of new
authorizations being created in the database but then never exposed to
the subscriber because of a failure later in the new-order flow, both by
reducing failures overall and by adding those authorizations in a
transaction which will be rolled back if there is a later failure.
Fixes#5577
* Make `sa.SetOrderError` passthrough.
* Create new proto message `sapb.SetOrderErrorRequest`
that includes only the order id and error to avoid passing around
unnecessary fields of an order.
Part of: #5533
* Make `sa.NewOrder` passthrough.
* Create a new proto message `sapb.NewOrderRequest`
that includes only the information needed to store a new order.
Part of: #5533
Samantha